Journal The Still Her Series · Part 2
Reading Health Claims
Reading a Certificate of Analysis
What a lab report actually tells you, line by line.
The first time someone sent me a "COA," I opened the PDF and just stared at it. Columns of numbers. Abbreviations like HPLC and MS. Something called a "retention time." A big bold 99.2% at the bottom that I assumed was good news.
I nodded like I understood. I didn't.
It turns out a Certificate of Analysis is one of the most useful documents you can ask for. It's also one of the easiest to fake, reuse, or misread. So let's walk through one together, line by line, the way I wish someone had done for me.
What a COA is, and why it matters
A Certificate of Analysis is a lab report for one specific batch of a product. It answers three questions:
- Is it what it says it is? (identity)
- How much of it is there, and how clean is it? (purity and strength)
- Is anything in there that shouldn't be? (contaminants)
You'll see COAs for supplements like protein powder, collagen, and creatine, for skincare ingredients, and for peptides. Since supplements aren't approved before they're sold (we covered that in Menopause Is Trending), a good COA is often the only proof you have that the bottle matches the label.
The key word is batch. A real COA is tied to one production lot, not to the product in general. A report from a batch made two years ago tells you nothing about the jar on your counter.
A COA, line by line
Every lab formats them a little differently, but a solid COA includes most of these. Here's what each part is and what to check.
| Section | What it tells you | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Lab name, address, and accreditation | Who did the testing | It should be a real, independent lab, ideally accredited to ISO/IEC 17025, the international standard for testing labs. A report from the seller's own "in-house" lab carries less weight. |
| Certificate or report number | A unique ID for this report | The lab should be able to look it up if you ask. |
| Product name | What was tested | It should match your product exactly, not something "similar." |
| Lot or batch number | Which production run was tested | It must match the lot number printed on your container. This is the single most important check. |
| Test date | When the sample was analyzed | Recent, and after the batch was made. A very old date is a warning sign. |
| Test methods | How each result was measured | Named methods, like HPLC, mass spectrometry (MS), or ICP-MS for heavy metals. |
| Results with specifications | The actual numbers, next to what's acceptable | Every result should have a number and units, plus a pass/fail limit. "Pass" with no number is weak. |
| Identity | Confirms the right compound is present | For peptides, look for mass spectrometry showing the measured molecular weight matches the expected one. |
| Purity and strength | How much of the right stuff, and how clean | For supplements, "potency" versus label claim. For peptides, both HPLC purity and net peptide content (more on this below). |
| Contaminants | What shouldn't be there | Heavy metals (lead, arsenic, cadmium, mercury), microbes, and solvents. For anything injectable, endotoxin and sterility testing too. |
| Signature and date | Who approved the results | A named person, not just a logo. |
The lot number match is worth repeating. As one industry guide puts it, the code on your product should take you, with no email or account required, to a COA for that same lot from a named, independent lab.
The numbers that trip people up
"99% pure" doesn't mean 99% of the vial is the peptide
This is the one that fooled me. On a peptide COA, the big purity number usually comes from a test called HPLC. It measures how much of the peptide material is the correct peptide, compared with other, incorrect peptide fragments.
What it doesn't measure is everything else in the powder. Freeze-dried peptides also contain water, leftover salts, and other non-peptide material that the HPLC test can't see. That's why peptide purity and peptide content are two different measurements.
The second number, net peptide content, tells you what percentage of the total weight is actually peptide. One manufacturer describes typical net peptide content as 70 to 90%.
So picture a vial labeled 10 mg at 99% purity. If its net peptide content is 80%, it holds roughly 7.9 mg of actual peptide, not 10. Both numbers can be perfectly honest. You just need both to understand what you have. A COA that only shows purity is telling you half the story.
Identity: is it even the right thing?
A high purity number only tells you that you have a pure something. Mass spectrometry (often written "MS" or "LC-MS") is what confirms which something. It weighs the molecule. The COA should show the expected molecular weight and the measured one, and they should match closely.
"ND" and detection limits
For contaminants, you'll often see "ND," meaning not detected. That's good, but a strong COA also lists the detection limit, the smallest amount the test could have found. "Not detected" with a sensitive test means a lot more than "not detected" with a rough one.
Red flags that a COA doesn't add up
A COA is just a PDF, and PDFs are easy to copy, edit, or reuse. Watch for these:
- The lot number doesn't match your container, or there's no lot number at all.
- No lab name, or a lab you can't find anywhere online.
- The "lab" is the seller. In-house testing isn't worthless, but it isn't independent.
- The same COA for every batch, or one that's years old.
- Suspiciously perfect numbers. 99.9% on everything, every time, with no variation from batch to batch.
- Results without numbers, like a column of "Pass" with no units or limits.
- Purity, but no identity test, or no net content for a peptide.
- No contaminant testing for something you'd swallow, apply to broken skin, or inject.
- Blurry, cropped, or edited-looking images, or fonts that change partway through.
- They won't share it, or only send it after you've paid.
How to verify one
- Match the lot number to your product. Every time.
- Look up the lab. Real accredited labs are listed in publicly searchable accreditation databases. Check that the lab exists and is accredited.
- Contact the lab directly using contact details you find yourself, not the ones on the PDF. Give them the report number and ask whether they issued it.
- Look for seals on supplements. USP Verified and NSF Certified mean an outside organization has already done this checking for you.
Your quick COA checklist
Save this for the next time someone sends you a COA.
One honest caveat: a perfect COA tells you a product is what it claims to be. It doesn't tell you the product works, or that it's right for you. That's a separate question, and it's the one to take to your doctor.
What's next in this series
Next up: What "Research Use Only" Means. You'll see that label on a lot of peptides sold online. I'll explain what it legally means, why it matters, and why it isn't a loophole.
Want articles picked for where you are right now? Take the 60-second quiz, What's your menopause season?
Sources
- LifeTein: How to Calculate the Peptide Concentration (purity versus net peptide content).
- AmbioPharm: Peptide content on a certificate of analysis.
- PrymaLab release on lot testing documentation, via Thailand Business News (net content arithmetic example).
- New Hope Network: Does the Supplement Bottle's Lot Code Open That Lot's Lab Report?
- Ayah Labs: How to Spot a Falsified Certificate of Analysis.
This article is for education only and isn't medical advice. A certificate of analysis describes a product's quality, not whether it's safe or effective for you. Talk with your healthcare provider before starting any new treatment or supplement.