Still Her

Health & Wellness Through Menopause

Free: What's your menopause season? Take the 60-second quiz →

Journal The Still Her Series · Part 4

Reading Health Claims

How to Spot a Safer Seller: Supplements, Skincare and Peptides

A checklist for telling a careful seller from a risky one.

Article 30 of 30 · 6 min read

A couple of years ago, I bought a "menopause support" supplement from an ad that popped up on my phone at 2 a.m. (Of course it was 2 a.m.) Glowing reviews, a doctor in a white coat, a countdown timer telling me the sale ended in 9 minutes.

It arrived in a plain bag with no lot number. The "doctor" turned out to be a stock photo. And the company's address, when I finally looked it up, was a mailbox store.

I wasn't hurt, just out $60. But it taught me something that's become the thread running through this whole series: what you buy matters, but who you buy it from matters just as much. So for our last article, let's put it all together.

Why this matters: nobody checks before it's sold

Here's something a lot of women don't realize. The FDA doesn't test supplements, skincare or research-use products before they hit the shelves. With supplements, the company is responsible for making sure its product is safe and matches the label, and the FDA usually steps in only after problems are reported.

That means the quality of what's in the bottle, jar or vial depends almost entirely on the seller. Good companies test their products carefully. Others cut corners, and you can't tell the difference by looking at a pretty label or a five-star review.

The good news: once you know what to look for, the safer sellers are pretty easy to spot.

Supplements and skincare: what to look for

Illustration of a supplement bottle, a skincare jar and a magnifying glass

Green flags:

  • A third-party seal. These mean an independent group checked that the product contains what the label says and isn't contaminated. Look for USP Verified, NSF Certified or NSF Certified for Sport, or Informed Choice / Informed Sport.
  • A lot number and expiration date printed on the package.
  • A real company. A physical address, a phone number that a human answers, and a clear return policy.
  • Honest claims. "Supports healthy bones" is a normal supplement claim. Anything that says it treats, cures or reverses a disease is breaking the rules.
  • A short, clear ingredient list with exact amounts, not a "proprietary blend" that hides how much of each ingredient you're getting.

Red flags:

  • "Miracle," "melts fat," "reverses aging," "doctors hate this," or "works like Ozempic"
  • Countdown timers, "only 3 left," and other pressure tactics
  • Doctors or reviews you can't verify (search the doctor's name; search the photo)
  • Automatic subscriptions that are hard to cancel
  • No contact information beyond a web form

Quick tip: search the brand name plus "FDA warning letter" before you buy. The FDA posts its warning letters online, and it only takes a minute.

Prescription drugs online: use a verified pharmacy

Illustration of a laptop and a shield

For anything that needs a prescription, like hormone therapy, GLP-1s, minoxidil pills or Addyi, the safest route is a licensed pharmacy.

A safe online pharmacy will:

  • Require a valid prescription from a licensed provider
  • Be licensed in the US and show you its license information
  • Have a US address and a licensed pharmacist you can talk to

How to check: the FDA's BeSafeRx program explains how to verify an online pharmacy, and the National Association of Boards of Pharmacy keeps a list of verified safe pharmacies. Sites ending in .pharmacy have been vetted.

Red flags: no prescription required, prices that seem too good to be true, shipping from overseas, or a site that only takes crypto or payment apps. Also remember that compounded versions of drugs aren't FDA-approved (more in The GLP-1 Question Every Woman Over 50 Is Asking, Answered).

Peptides and research-use-only products

Throughout this series, we've talked about peptides like BPC-157, GHK-Cu, NAD+ and PT-141, and about the "research use only" (RUO) versions many women buy online. As I've said in every one of those articles: these aren't FDA-approved, and if you choose to go this route, it's on you to make sure what you're getting is real. This is the part where the seller matters most.

Green flags:

  • A reputable US company with a real business address, a phone number, a track record and people you can actually reach.
  • A certificate of analysis (COA) for every batch, and you can match the lot number on the COA to the lot number on your vial.
  • Independent lab testing. The COA comes from a third-party lab, ideally one accredited to ISO/IEC 17025, not from the seller itself. You should be able to look the lab up, and many let you verify a report on their website.
  • The right tests. Identity (it's actually the peptide on the label), net peptide content (how much is really in there, not just a purity percentage), and endotoxin testing. Sterility testing is a plus.
  • Proper shipping and storage, like cold packs and clear storage instructions, since many peptides break down with heat.
  • Clear, honest labeling and secure, normal payment options like credit cards.

Red flags:

  • No COA, a COA that's blurry or generic, or one where the lot number doesn't match your vial
  • A COA from a lab you can't find, or the seller's own "in-house" testing only
  • Prices dramatically lower than everyone else's
  • Ships from overseas, or won't say where products are made
  • Sold through Instagram DMs, Facebook groups or Telegram
  • Crypto-only or payment-app-only checkout. Researchers at Chainalysis have traced some gray-market peptide sellers back to questionable overseas suppliers.
  • "Cures," "miracle" or guaranteed results

Why this matters so much: when researchers bought "research" GLP-1s online, some vials held only a fraction of what the label promised, and one had high levels of bacterial toxins. A good COA from an independent lab is how you protect yourself from that.

Reading a Certificate of Analysis walks through how to read a COA line by line, and What "Research Use Only" Means lays out all your peptide options.

Your safer-seller checklist

Illustration of a checklist and a shopping bag

Screenshot this or print it, and run through it before you buy anything you'll swallow, apply or inject.

For any product:

For supplements and skincare:

For prescription drugs:

For peptides and research-use products:

That's a wrap on the series

We started this series for every woman who's been pushing through menopause on her own, convinced she's falling apart. Here's what we want you to take with you:

  • You're not falling apart. You're changing. And change can be understood and worked with.
  • The basics carry most of the weight. Protein, lifting, walking, sleep, a little less wine, and your people.
  • You have more options than you were told, from hormone therapy and GLP-1s to creatine, minoxidil and peptides.
  • Be a smart consumer. Read the studies, ask your doctor good questions, and buy from sellers you can trust.
  • Your next 30 years can be some of your best.

Thank you for reading, for sharing these with your friends, and for every message you've sent me. You're still you. You're still her.

Not sure where to start? Take our quiz: What's your menopause season? It takes two minutes and points you to the articles that fit where you are right now. Or go back to the beginning, You're Not Falling Apart, You're Changing, and start from the top.

Sources

  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration. BeSafeRx: your source for online pharmacy information. Link
  • National Association of Boards of Pharmacy. Safe.Pharmacy. Link
  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Warning letters. Link
  • USP Verified dietary supplements. Link
  • NSF certified products. Link
  • Chainalysis. The gray-market peptide crypto boom. Link
  • Belcourt, Ly & White. Online semaglutide and tirzepatide sold "for research purposes." Annals of Pharmacotherapy, 2025. Link

This article is for education only and isn't medical advice. Peptides sold as "research use only" are not FDA-approved and are not intended for human use. Talk with your doctor before starting any supplement, medication or peptide.

New articles, by email

Never miss a new article.

Pop your email in below and we'll send you every new article as soon as it's published. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

You're in. We'll email you as soon as the next article goes live.