Still Her

Health & Wellness Through Menopause

Free: What's your menopause season? Take the 60-second quiz →

Journal The Still Her Series · Part 2

Reading Health Claims

Menopause Is Trending: How to Tell If a Claim Is Real

Five questions to ask before you buy or believe anything.

Article 9 of 30 · 7 min read

The other night I spent 20 minutes scrolling before bed. In that time I was promised:

  • A gummy that would "melt menopause belly fat"
  • A tea that would "balance your hormones naturally"
  • A doctor-looking woman in scrubs selling a $79 "hormone reset" kit
  • An influencer who swore one supplement had "cured" her hot flashes in a week

Five years ago, it was hard to find anyone talking about menopause online. Now it's everywhere. Honestly, that's mostly a good thing. We're finally talking about it out loud.

But the more attention menopause gets, the more people want to sell us something. And when you're exhausted, sweating at 3 a.m., and desperate to feel like yourself again, it's hard to tell real help from a really good sales pitch.

So this article starts Part 2 of the series: learning to read health claims like a pro. You don't need a science degree. You just need a few questions to ask.

What researchers found when they checked our feeds

Illustration of a woman scrolling her phone

I wanted to know how much of what I was seeing was actually true. Researchers have started checking, and the results are eye-opening.

None of this means you should stop learning online. (You're reading this online, after all.) It means you should read with your eyes open.

Red flags that you're reading a sales pitch

After a while, you start to recognize the patterns. Here are the ones I watch for now.

You see... What it often means
"Balances your hormones" or "hormone reset" A vague promise with nothing measurable behind it. Real treatments name what they change.
"Melts belly fat" or "no diet or exercise needed" If it worked like that, it would be front-page news, not an Instagram ad.
"Cured my hot flashes in a week" One person's story. It might be true for her, but it isn't evidence for you.
"Doctors don't want you to know this" A tactic to make you distrust real care, so you'll trust the seller instead.
"All natural, so no side effects" Natural doesn't mean safe. Plenty of plants are powerful, and some interact with medications.
Countdown timers, "only 3 left," or a big discount that ends tonight Pressure designed to stop you from thinking it over.
A white coat and a confident voice, but no name, credentials, or sources Possibly not a real clinician. Look them up.
"Clinically proven" with no link to a study Ask: proven by whom, in whom, and for what?
Every problem has the same answer, and it's their product Real health is rarely one-size-fits-all.

One red flag doesn't automatically make something useless. But when you see three or four together, it's time to close the tab.

How to tell strong evidence from weak

Illustration of a research paper and a balance scale

When someone says "studies show," it helps to know that not all studies are created equal. I think of it as a ladder, from weakest at the bottom to strongest at the top.

Rung Kind of evidence
5 (strongest) A review of many trials
4 A randomized controlled trial
3 An observational study
2 A study in mice or in a dish
1 (weakest) A testimonial

The higher up the ladder, the more you can trust the result. Here's how I use it in real life:

  • A testimonial is where a question starts, not where it ends. "It worked for me" is worth hearing, but it can't tell you whether it will work for you.
  • A study in mice or in a dish is interesting, but lots of things that work in a lab never pan out in people.
  • An observational study might find that women who do X have less of Y. That's a clue, but it doesn't prove X caused it. Maybe those women also exercise more, or sleep better.
  • A randomized controlled trial is the real test. People are randomly split into groups, and one group gets a placebo, so researchers can see whether the treatment actually made the difference.
  • A review of many trials gives the clearest picture, because one study can be a fluke.

A few more questions worth asking about any study:

  1. Was it done in women like me? A study in 25-year-old men may not tell you much about a 55-year-old woman.
  2. How many people? Ten people is a pilot. Thousands is more convincing.
  3. How big was the effect? "Significant" in science means "probably not chance," not "big." A hot flash going from 8 a day to 7 is real, but is it worth the cost?
  4. Who paid for it? Industry-funded studies aren't automatically wrong, but it's worth knowing.

What the label is (and isn't) telling you

This part surprised me most. I always assumed that if something was sold in a store, someone had checked that it worked. For supplements, that's not how it works.

Supplements aren't approved before they're sold. In the U.S., the FDA does not approve dietary supplements before they reach consumers. It's up to the manufacturer to make sure the product is safe and that its claims are truthful. Prescription drugs, by contrast, have to prove they're safe and effective before they can be sold.

Watch for the asterisk. When a supplement says something like "supports hormonal balance" or "promotes restful sleep," that's called a structure/function claim. By law, the label must include a disclaimer saying the FDA has not evaluated the claim and that the product isn't intended to "diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease." That little asterisk is worth reading.

"FDA approved" on a supplement is a red flag. The FDA has reminded consumers that the phrase is rarely accurate for supplements. "Made in an FDA-registered facility" can be true, but it only means the factory is registered. It says nothing about whether the product works.

Look for third-party testing. Since no one checks supplements before they're sold, independent seals like USP Verified or NSF Certified are useful. They confirm the bottle contains what the label says, at the dose it says, without harmful contaminants. They don't prove it works, but they do prove you're getting what you paid for.

The next three articles go deeper into this. Peptides in Five Minutes, Reading a Certificate of Analysis, and What "Research Use Only" Means cover three areas where labels can be especially confusing.

Five questions before you buy or believe

Illustration of a checklist and a magnifying glass

I keep these on a sticky note by my computer. Run any claim through them before you click "add to cart."

  1. Who's telling me this, and what do they get out of it? Are they selling the product, earning a commission, or running a clinic? That doesn't make them wrong, but it's worth weighing.
  2. What's the actual claim? Pin down exactly what it promises to change. "Fewer hot flashes" can be tested. "Balances your hormones" can't.
  3. Where's the evidence, and how strong is it? Is there a study? Was it in people? In women like me? Where does it fall on the ladder?
  4. What are the risks and side effects? Anything strong enough to help is strong enough to have side effects or interact with your medications. If no downsides are mentioned, be suspicious.
  5. What would my doctor or pharmacist say? Ask them. Pharmacists are wonderful for checking supplement interactions, and they're usually free to talk to.

And yes, this applies to us, too. This site sometimes links to products, and when we do, we'll tell you clearly. Hold everything you read here to the same five questions. That's exactly what I'd want my friends to do.

What's next in this series

Next up: Peptides in Five Minutes. Peptides are one of the most talked-about (and most confusing) topics in women's wellness right now. I'll explain what they are in plain English, what the research does and doesn't show, and what to watch out for.

Want articles picked for where you are right now? Take the 60-second quiz, What's your menopause season?

Sources

This article is for education only and isn't medical advice. Talk with your healthcare provider or pharmacist before starting any new treatment or supplement.

New articles, by email

Never miss a new article.

Pop your email in below and we'll send you every new article as soon as it's published. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

You're in. We'll email you as soon as the next article goes live.