Journal The Still Her Series · Part 3
Weight & Metabolism
Wellness Without Extremes
No cleanses, no 5 a.m. ice baths. What actually holds up.
Maybe you've tried a three-day juice cleanse. A friend swore it "reset" her, and you were desperate for a reset. You'd been tired for months, your jeans didn't fit, and it felt like your body had stopped listening to you.
By the afternoon of day two, you were shaky, headachy, and so cranky you snapped at someone for chewing too loud. On day three you gave up and ate a grilled cheese standing over the sink. Then you felt like a failure on top of feeling tired.
That cleanse cost me $120 and taught me one thing: I don't need a reset. I need things I can actually keep doing on a Tuesday.
The wellness world loves extremes. Cleanses, cold plunges at dawn, 30-day challenges, cutting out entire food groups. Some of it is harmless and some of it isn't, but almost none of it is built for a woman in her 50s who has a life to live. So let's talk about what actually works, without punishing yourself.
Why extremes backfire after menopause
At 25, you could crash diet for a wedding and bounce back. At 55, extremes cost more, for a few reasons.
You lose muscle along with fat. When you cut calories hard without exercise, a big chunk of the weight you lose can be muscle. A review of 52 studies in middle-aged and older adults found that in most of the diet-only groups, at least 15% of the weight lost was lean mass like muscle. When people added exercise, far fewer groups lost that much. After menopause, muscle is the thing we're working hardest to keep (more in Why Muscle Loss Speeds Up After Menopause).
Your body is already under stress. Hot flashes, broken sleep, and big hormone shifts are a lot for one body to handle. Piling a punishing plan on top usually makes you more tired and more irritable, not less.
All-or-nothing turns into nothing. This is the big one for me. Extreme plans are hard to keep up. When you slip, and everyone does, it feels like you've failed. Then you quit altogether until the next Monday, the next month, the next "fresh start."
Trends you can skip (or at least not stress about)
I'm not here to make fun of anyone's routine. If something makes you feel good and isn't hurting you, keep it. But you don't need any of these to be healthy.
Detox cleanses. Your liver and kidneys are already doing the detoxing, every day, for free. A critical review of detox diets found very little clinical evidence that they remove toxins or help with lasting weight loss, and no randomized trials of commercial detox programs in humans. The weight that comes off is mostly water, and it comes right back.
Extreme fasting and cutting out whole food groups. Some women do well with a gentle eating window, like finishing dinner by 7. But long fasts and "no carbs ever" rules make it hard to get enough protein and fiber, which are exactly what our bodies need more of now.
Punishing workouts. You don't need to work out until you can't walk. Two or three strength sessions a week and plenty of walking will do more for you than a brutal bootcamp you dread. And recovery matters too (see Why Am I Still Sore 3 Days Later?).
Expensive gadgets and 5 a.m. ice baths. If you love your cold plunge, great. But if your routine requires a lot of money or misery, it probably won't last. The things that work best for most of us are boring and cheap.
The boring basics that actually work
Here's the not-very-exciting truth. Almost everything that helps us feel better after menopause comes down to a handful of basics, done most days:
- Eat protein at every meal. About 30–35 grams each time, to protect your muscle. (See The One Thing Most Women Over 50 Aren't Eating Enough Of.)
- Lift something two or three times a week. Strength training is the closest thing we have to an anti-aging plan.
- Walk. You don't need 10,000 steps. A big 2022 study of nearly 50,000 adults found the benefit for longevity leveled off at about 6,000–8,000 steps a day for people 60 and older, and 8,000–10,000 for younger adults.
- Eat your fiber. Vegetables, fruit, beans and whole grains keep you full and your gut happy.
- Protect your sleep. Cool room, steady bedtime, less wine at night.
- Drink less alcohol. Not necessarily none. Just less. (See Wine O'Clock Hits Different Now.)
- See your people. Walks with a friend, dinner with your family, a phone call with your sister. Connection is good for your health, not just your mood.
None of these will go viral. But they're the things that actually work, and every one of them is something you can do on a normal, busy Tuesday.
Small habits and the 80% rule
We've all heard it takes 21 days to build a habit. The research says it takes longer, and that's actually good news.
In a well-known study on habit formation, it took people a median of 66 days for a new daily habit to start feeling automatic. Some people got there in 18 days, and others took much longer. Simpler habits, like drinking a glass of water with lunch, stuck faster than harder ones, like exercise. And here's my favorite part: missing a day now and then didn't stop the habit from forming.
So you don't have to be perfect. You just have to keep coming back. That's why we love the 80% rule. If you're doing the basics about 80% of the time, you're doing great. The birthday cake, the skipped workout, the night you stay up too late watching a show: those are the other 20%, and they're part of a good life too.
If you want to start, pick one small thing. Add a walk after dinner. Put a hard-boiled egg next to your morning coffee. Do it for a couple of months, until you don't have to think about it, then add the next thing.
If you're trying to lose weight
I know a lot of you are reading this because the scale has crept up and won't come back down, no matter what you try. We get it.
We wrote a whole article on exactly this: The Easiest Way to Lose Weight After Menopause (Seriously, It's This Simple). It's one of our favorites. It lays out three simple steps that work with your body instead of against it: understanding your options with GLP-1 medications and talking with your doctor about them, high-protein meal prep that makes eating well almost automatic, and a walking pad so you can add steps without finding extra time.
No cleanses, no counting every bite, no punishing workouts. If weight is on your mind, start there.
The bottom line
You don't need a reset, a cleanse, or a 30-day challenge. You need a few simple habits you can keep doing for years: protein, lifting, walking, fiber, sleep, a little less wine, and time with the people you love.
You don't need anything extreme. Eat the birthday cake. Skip a workout now and then. But most days, walk, lift, eat real food, and go to bed at a decent hour. It's not flashy, and it works.
Be kind to yourself. This is a long game, and you're allowed to play it gently.
What's next in this series
Next up: Your Next 30 Years. We'll zoom out. Menopause isn't the end of anything. For a lot of us, it's the start of a stretch of life that can be the best one yet. We'll talk about what to focus on now so you feel strong, sharp, and like yourself at 65, 75, and beyond.
Not sure where you are in all of this? Take our quiz: What's your menopause season? It takes two minutes and points you to the articles that fit where you are right now.
Sources
- Weinheimer EM, Sands LP, Campbell WW. A systematic review of the separate and combined effects of energy restriction and exercise on fat-free mass in middle-aged and older adults. Nutrition Reviews, 2010. Link
- Klein AV, Kiat H. Detox diets for toxin elimination and weight management: a critical review of the evidence. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 2015. Link
- Paluch AE, et al. Daily steps and all-cause mortality: a meta-analysis of 15 international cohorts. Lancet Public Health, 2022. Link
- Lally P, et al. How are habits formed: modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology, 2010. Link
This article is for education only and isn't medical advice. Talk with your doctor before making big changes to your diet, exercise, or medications.